Comp 2014 Roundup

I have a couple more reviews to write, but those aren’t happening until a little post-comp. So it’s time for a wrap-up post.

comp14dist

My voting distribution.

In line with the trends of the previous few years, there were relatively few utter-bullshit games. Even the games which I gave 1s and 2s were, I think, sincerely intended. If you look back over comps from a decade ago, they were choked with trash: coding exercises, troll entries, things so badly-made and confusedly-conceived as to be effectively unplayable. (Spring Thing was originally created as The Comp Without All The Crap In It.)

Recommended

  • With Those We Love Alive: familiar Porpentine territory of lurid, oppressive, Giger-meets-Calvino horrors, but with craft that continues to develop and a potent-as-fuck gimmick. Clearly the best game in the comp, by my reckoning; this is the first time I’ve given out a 10 straight up.
  • Krypteia: a traditional adventure-game format turned into a weird Dionysian night-journey about queerness and self-liberation.
  • Creatures Such As We: ambitious if flawed attempt to explore contemporary issues in game design theory through a dating sim on the moon.
  •  Hunger Daemon: having tested it I am unreliable on the subject, but this seems like clearly the strongest of the parser entries. Good-naturedly gentle humour, solid craft, has some positions but doesn’t push hard on ’em.

Everybody has a specific set of things that they want out of IF, though, so here are some more specific recommendations according to what kind of experience the games aim to deliver.

Emotion: Venus Meets Venus treats the turmoil of early relationships with raw honesty. With Those We Love Alive serves up Porpentine’s signature blend of alienation, disgust, complicity and longing in a deeply-horrific fantasy world.

Beauty: With Those We Love Alive is a high-craft piece with tight, powerful, image-rich prose. Eidolon features an evocative, moody environment.

Concept: Krypteia and Creatures Such As We require the most non-puzzly processing.

Fun: Jacqueline, Jungle Queen is a good-natured, irreverently silly romp , though you may have to forgive its occasionally shaky implementation. Hunger Daemon (which, full disclosure once again, I tested) is somewhat less randomly zany and considerably more robust. And if you have a bunch of friends together, some drinks and a penchant for snark, Slasher Swamp may actually offer some of the best entertainment of the whole comp.

Challenge: Fifteen Minutes is a tough but fair time-travel puzzle. Ugly Oafs might be worth a look if you want pure wordplay puzzles with little pretense at fiction. Missive is also a crosswordy kind of game, though with a stronger narrative element.

Experiments: There were a lot of experiments this year- some largely aesthetic, others more substantial. As is usual in experiments, many of them were not really all that great overall. For having-an-argument-about-theory purposes, I recommend looking at Raik, Origins, Missive, Creatures Such As We, With Those We Love Alive, AlethiCorp, Transparent, Icepunk, Zest and Caroline.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in cyoa, interactive fiction, parser-based, review and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Comp 2014 Roundup

  1. Victor Gijsbers says:

    Thanks, Sam, very useful to someone like me who hasn’t managed to play more than three entries. 🙂

  2. Pingback: Post-IFComp commentary | As Inclination Leads Me

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s